Skip to content
Book a strategy call
DARKSTAR_INSIGHTS 9 MIN READ SEO

Backlink Building for Law Firms: Authority Without the Spam

What Google counts as link spam, what the ethics rules say about paying for placements, and the link building methods that hold up for law firms.

Links from other websites still help a law firm rank. Google says so in its own documentation. The trouble is how most firms get them. A lot of what is sold to lawyers as “link building” is paid placement that Google classifies as link spam, and some of it raises bar ethics questions as well. This guide covers what Google’s rules actually say, what your state’s version of Rule 7.2 says about paying for placements, and the methods that earn links a firm can defend.

Do backlinks still matter for law firm SEO?

Yes. Google’s guide to its ranking systems lists link analysis and PageRank among the systems it uses to work out “what pages are about and which might be most helpful in response to a query.” Its SEO Starter Guide adds that most new pages Google finds are found through links.

Links are one input among many, though. Google does not publish a ranking of its signals, and a strong link profile will not rescue a thin practice page. For local searches, your Google Business Profile and reviews carry much of the weight. Think of links as the outside evidence that your firm and your content are worth citing.

What does Google count as link spam?

Google’s spam policies list the practices it treats as link spam. Several are sold to law firms every day:

  • Buying or selling links for ranking purposes, including “exchanging money for links, or posts that contain links.”
  • Excessive link exchanges, and partner pages built only to cross-link.
  • Advertorials where payment is received for articles that include links that pass ranking credit, and “links with optimized anchor text in articles, guest posts, or press releases distributed on other sites.”
  • Requiring a link as part of a contract or terms of service without letting the site owner qualify it.
  • Low-quality directory or bookmark site links.
  • Forum comments with optimized links in the post or signature.

Paid placements are not banned outright. Google says it understands that “buying and selling links is a normal part of the economy of the web for advertising and sponsorship purposes,” and that a paid link is fine if it carries rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow", which tells Google not to count it for ranking. What is against the rules is paying for a link that is meant to pass ranking credit.

Google also detects this at scale. When it announced the December 2022 link spam update, Google said its SpamBrain system can “detect both sites buying links, and sites used for the purpose of passing outgoing links,” and that credit from those links is lost when they are neutralized. Spam policy violations can also bring a manual action, where a site ranks lower or drops out of results. So the realistic outcome of a cheap link package is usually money spent on links Google ignores, with some risk of worse.

What does a typical bad link vendor sell?

What the vendor sellsHow Google treats itEthics flag for lawyers
“20 high-DA links a month” on guest post sitesPaid posts with links are link spam unless marked sponsoredFirm is responsible for vendor conduct (Rules 5.3, 8.4(a))
Private blog network linksSites built to pass outgoing links are a SpamBrain targetSame
Paid inclusion in “best lawyers in [city]” listsPaid link; should be sponsored or nofollowMay be paying for a recommendation (Rule 7.2(b))
Hundreds of generic directory submissionsNamed as low-quality directory linksListings must not be misleading (Rule 7.1)
Link swaps with other firmsExcessive exchanges are link spamReciprocal referral deals have their own rules (Rule 7.2(b)(4))

A useful test: if a vendor quotes a fixed number of links per month at a fixed price, ask where each link comes from and whether money changes hands with the site. If it does, the link should be marked sponsored, and then it will not help rankings.

Can a law firm pay for links under the ethics rules?

The ethics question is separate from Google’s, and both apply. Rule 7.2(b) of the ABA Model Rules bars a lawyer from giving anything of value to a person for recommending the lawyer’s services, with listed exceptions. The first exception lets a lawyer pay the reasonable costs of advertising. Colorado’s version of the rule, which follows the Model Rule closely, spells out in comment [3] that this includes online directory listings, sponsorship fees, domain names and internet advertising, and that a lawyer may pay vendors such as publicists and website designers.

Comment [2] draws the line. A communication is a recommendation if it “endorses or vouches for a lawyer’s credentials, abilities, competence, character, or other professional qualities.” Directory listings that list lawyers by practice area “without more” are not recommendations. A site that charges you to appear in its “top personal injury lawyers” article, written as an endorsement, is closer to the line. Comment [5] adds that a lawyer may not pay a lead generator that implies it is recommending the lawyer, and points to Rule 5.3 (supervising nonlawyers) and Rule 8.4(a) (violating the rules through the acts of another). In practice, that means what your link vendor does in your name is your problem.

Two practical rules follow. Pay for advertising and listings openly, and expect those links to be marked sponsored. Do not pay anyone for an endorsement dressed up as editorial content. Each state adopts its own version of Rule 7.2, and some add requirements (Colorado, for example, adds a required disclaimer for specialist claims), so check yours before you sign a placement deal.

Which link building methods work for law firms?

The methods that last have one thing in common: someone links to you because your firm did or published something worth pointing to. Google’s ranking guide says it tries to show original content, “including original reporting, ahead of those who merely cite it,” and that logic carries over to who gets linked.

Original local data

Reporters and other sites link to the source of a number. A firm can produce real numbers from public records: crash data from your state transportation department or NHTSA’s fatality database for your county, court filing counts for a case type, or a year-over-year look at DUI arrests from your state’s published reports. Keep the method on the page, name the source, and have an attorney explain what the numbers mean for people in your area. Avoid publishing “average settlement” figures from your own cases unless the clients consent and the presentation meets Rule 7.1; results can mislead without context.

Expert commentary for reporters

Local news is one of the best link sources a firm can get, and the work is mostly being available and quick. Read your local outlets, learn which reporters cover courts, traffic, labor or immigration, and offer short, clear comment when a story touches your practice. Request services connect sources with reporters: HARO, which Cision shut down and then sold to Featured.com in April 2025, now runs again under the new owner, and Qwoted is another option. Answer only where you have real expertise.

One limit: when commentary touches a client matter, the duty of confidentiality applies. ABA Formal Opinion 480 (2018) says lawyers who blog or comment publicly may not reveal information relating to a representation, “including information contained in a public record,” unless the rules allow it.

A reporter holding a microphone interviews a woman seated in a bright room
A quote in a local news story is often the strongest link a firm earns all year.

Resources other sites want to cite

Legal aid groups, libraries, nonprofits and other lawyers link to clear, accurate guides. A plain-language walkthrough of your state’s expungement process, a checklist for the first week after a workplace injury, or a guide to what happens at a first immigration court hearing can earn links for years. It has to be better than what already exists: more specific to your state, more current, and written by the attorney who does the work. A steady content system makes this repeatable.

Community and bar work

Teaching a CLE, serving on a bar committee, speaking at a community college, or volunteering with a local nonprofit often leads to a speaker page, an event listing or a news mention. Those links are local and relevant. Sponsorships are fine too, but be clear about what they are: if you paid for the placement, the link is a paid link, and Google asks that it be marked rel="sponsored". Sponsor things because the community and the visibility are worth it, not as a ranking tactic.

Volunteers at an outdoor charity table talking with an older man in a wheelchair, with donation boxes nearby
Real community work tends to produce local mentions, but a link bought through a sponsorship should be marked as sponsored.

Articles for real publications

Writing for your state bar journal, a local business journal or a trade publication your clients read is different from buying a guest post. The editor chooses the piece, the audience is real, and nobody is paid for the link. Google’s concern is paid placements and guest posts stuffed with optimized anchor text, so write for the publication’s readers, skip the keyword anchors, and let the author bio link to your attorney page.

Directories that people actually use

Your state bar directory, Justia, Avvo, FindLaw and practice-specific associations are worth keeping accurate because prospects and referral sources look at them, and because consistent firm details help Google match your firm across the web. Do not expect paid directory links to move rankings, and skip the mass submission services entirely.

A woman speaking at a wooden lectern to a small seated audience in a conference room
Speaking at a CLE or community event often earns a speaker page that links back to the attorney.

How do you judge whether a link is worth getting?

Ask four questions. Would a person who reads that page plausibly want to visit yours? Is the site relevant to your practice or your city? Did the site choose to link to you, or did you pay? Does the page have real readers? A link that passes all four is worth chasing even if it is nofollow. Google has treated nofollow, sponsored and ugc as hints rather than strict rules since March 1, 2020, and a mention in the right story still sends referral traffic and builds recognition.

Be careful with tool scores like Domain Authority or Domain Rating. They are useful for rough comparison, but Google’s guidance on third-party SEO tools notes that these tools “don’t have access to our internal ranking data.” A vendor report that only shows a rising score tells you little.

Should you disavow old spammy links?

Usually not. Google’s disavow tool help page says that in most cases it “can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, so most sites will not need to use this tool.” Google suggests disavowing only if you have many spammy links and they have caused, or are likely to cause, a manual action. If a past vendor bought links for you, check Search Console’s Manual actions report first.

How do you run a link program month to month?

  1. Publish one resource or data piece a quarter that is built to be cited.
  2. Look at which sites link to the firms that outrank you. Local news, bar associations and community groups that linked to them may cover you too.
  3. Set a weekly time block for reporter requests and local news follow-up.
  4. Keep a list of every placement you pay for, and confirm those links are marked sponsored.
  5. Review new links in Search Console’s Links report each month, and judge the program by referral traffic, rankings for your main practice pages and signed cases, not by a tool score.

This is slower than buying a package, and it does not produce a fixed number of links each month. It does produce links that hold up when Google updates its spam systems and when a bar regulator reads your marketing. See how we approach it on our backlinks and AI citations page, or start with the full law firm SEO guide.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central, “Spam policies for Google web search,” August 2026
  2. Google Search Central, “A Guide to Google Search Ranking Systems,” December 2025
  3. Google Search Central, “SEO Starter Guide,” December 2025
  4. Google Search Central, “Qualify your outbound links to Google,” December 2025
  5. Google Search Central Blog, “December 2022 link spam update,” December 2022
  6. Google Search Central Blog, “Evolving ‘nofollow’: new ways to identify the nature of links,” September 2019
  7. Google Search Central, “Google Search’s Guidance on Third-Party SEO Tools & Advice,” June 2026
  8. Search Console Help, “Disavow links to your site,” accessed November 2026
  9. Colorado Rules of Professional Conduct, “Rule 7.2: Communications Concerning a Lawyer’s Services: Specific Rules” (with comments), as amended September 2020
  10. ABA Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility, “Formal Opinion 480: Confidentiality Obligations for Lawyer Blogging and Other Public Commentary,” March 2018
  11. Cision (via AAP), “Cision Announces Sale of Help A Reporter Out (HARO) to Featured.com,” April 2025

Want this handled for your firm?

Darkstar runs marketing for law firms end to end: SEO, content, reviews, ads, and call tracking, with a live dashboard so you always know what is working. Book a strategy call.

Book a strategy call →
JW
Founder, Darkstar. 14+ years engineering growth systems for elite law firms. $500M+ in attributed revenue across 500+ practices.
Share
Own Your Space.

Ready to direct your growth?