Most law firms have plenty of happy clients and too few reviews to show for it. The fix is not complicated: ask every client, at the right moment, with a link that works on a phone, and reply to what comes in. The hard part is doing it inside three sets of rules at once: Google’s review policy, the FTC’s rules on reviews, and your state bar’s version of the Model Rules. This guide covers all three and gives you a process your staff can run every week.
Why do Google reviews matter so much for a law firm?
Two reasons: they affect where you show up, and they affect whether people call.
On ranking, Google is direct. Its local ranking help page says “more reviews and positive ratings can help your business’s local ranking,” and it lists responding to reviews among its tips. Reviews also feed Google’s map results and the profile that appears when someone searches your firm by name.
On the decision to call, BrightLocal’s Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 (1,002 US adults, published February 2026) found:
- 97% of consumers read reviews for local businesses.
- 74% look for reviews written in the last three months.
- 47% will not use a business with fewer than 20 reviews.
- 31% will only use a business rated 4.5 stars or higher.
- 89% expect the business owner to respond to reviews.
The survey covers local businesses in general, not law firms specifically. Still, the pattern is clear for anyone choosing a lawyer from a map listing: a steady flow of recent reviews matters more than a big count that stopped growing two years ago.
The same survey found 45% of consumers now use AI tools such as ChatGPT or Google’s AI features to find local businesses. Those tools summarize what is already public about you, including your reviews. Specific, recent reviews give them something accurate to say. You cannot script what a client writes, but asking soon after a good outcome tends to produce reviews that describe what you actually did.
What are the rules? Google, the FTC and your state bar
The rules overlap, and the strictest one controls. Here is how they line up.
| Practice | FTC | State bars (examples) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Asking every client for an honest review | Allowed | Allowed | Allowed (Texas Op. 685, NYSBA Op. 1286) |
| Asking only clients you think are happy (“review gating”) | Prohibited | Misleading if it skews the reviews | Risk under Rule 7.1 and 8.4(c) |
| Gift, discount or fee credit for a review | Prohibited, even for honest reviews | Allowed only if not tied to sentiment and disclosed | Varies. NY allows a nominal gift not tied to content. Rule 7.2(b) limits paying for recommendations |
| Reviews from staff, friends or family | Prohibited (conflict of interest) | Insider reviews need disclosure | Risk under Rule 7.1 and 8.4(c) |
| Writing the review for the client | Risky under the fake engagement policy | Fake reviews are prohibited | NY 1286: do not draft it |
| Bonus to staff for each positive review | Not addressed | Not addressed | Ohio Adv. Op. 2023-11: not allowed |
The sources behind each column:
- Google. Its prohibited content policy bars businesses from offering “payment, discounts, free goods and/or services” for reviews, from asking employees or others with a conflict of interest to review, and from any effort to “discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers.” Its help page on getting reviews says incentives are “strictly prohibited.”
- FTC. The Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule (16 CFR Part 465, effective October 21, 2024) bans fake reviews, incentives conditioned on positive sentiment, undisclosed insider reviews, and using threats or intimidation to suppress negative reviews. Courts can impose civil penalties for knowing violations. The FTC’s Endorsement Guides FAQ addresses gating directly: asking only customers “more likely to be happy” is “misleading if it substantially skews the favorability of the reviews.”
- State bars. Texas Ethics Opinion 685 (2020) lets lawyers ask clients for reviews, but not for false or misleading statements, and says a lawyer who learns a client posted a false favorable statement must take reasonable steps to get it corrected or removed. NYSBA Opinion 1286 (September 2025) allows asking former clients for Google reviews and a nominal gift not tied to what they write, as long as the lawyer does not draft the review. Ohio’s Board of Professional Conduct said in Advisory Opinion 2023-11 that a bonus to nonlawyer staff triggered by a positive review is improper fee sharing.
The practical rule for a firm that wants to stay safe everywhere: ask every client, offer nothing, write nothing for them, and keep staff and family off your profile. Then check your own state’s opinions, because bar rules vary and this is not legal advice about your jurisdiction.
A review process your staff can run

1. Pick the moment for each practice area
Ask when the work is done and the client feels it. For personal injury, that is usually when the settlement is disbursed. For criminal defense, after a dismissal or a good plea. For family law, when the decree is entered. For estate planning, after the documents are signed. Write the moment into your closing checklist for each practice area so the ask happens every time, not only when someone remembers.
Ask every client who reaches that point, not only the ones you think loved you. That is what keeps you inside Google’s and the FTC’s rules. If a client is unhappy, the right response is to fix the problem, not to keep them away from the review link.
2. Make the ask personal
A short message from the lawyer or paralegal who worked the case lands better than a generic system email. Use the client’s name and send one link. For example:
“Maria, thank you for trusting us with your case. If you have a minute, an honest review on Google helps other people decide whether we are the right fit. Here is the link: [link]. Either way, it was a privilege to work with you.”
Notice what the message does not do. It does not ask for five stars, suggest what to write, or offer anything in return.

3. Send a link that opens the review box
Google lets you create a review link or QR code from your Business Profile. Use that link, not your homepage. Text it, because most people will write the review on their phone. Before you roll it out, test the link on an iPhone and an Android phone, logged in and logged out of Google.
4. Watch confidentiality in the ask itself
Some clients do not want anyone to know they hired a lawyer: criminal, immigration, divorce and bankruptcy clients especially. A review on Google is public and tied to their account. Let them decide, make clear that saying no is fine, and never send the request to a shared email or family phone. NYSBA Opinion 1286 flags this risk for immigration clients in particular.
5. Reply to reviews without revealing anything
Replies help. Google lists them as a ranking tip, and 89% of consumers in the BrightLocal survey expect them. But Model Rule 1.6 applies to replies, including replies to positive reviews. ABA Formal Opinion 496 collects state opinions on this, including West Virginia’s view that lawyers may respond to positive or negative reviews but may not disclose confidential information while doing it.
For a positive review, a simple “Thank you for taking the time to write this. We appreciate it.” is enough. Do not add case details, even ones the client already shared. For negative reviews, see our guide on handling bad reviews.

Where review programs go wrong
- Gating. Sending a “How did we do?” survey and only passing happy clients to Google. Many review tools offer this as a setting. It is exactly what Google and the FTC object to. A private feedback survey is fine as long as every client also gets the Google link.
- Asking only when someone remembers. Reviews come in bursts, then stop for months. Put the ask in the closing checklist.
- Incentives through the back door. A raffle for “everyone who leaves a review” is still an incentive under Google’s policy.
- Review bonuses for staff. Reward good client service in other ways. Ohio has said a bonus triggered by a positive review is improper.
- Over-sharing in replies. “We were glad to get your DUI dismissed” confirms a client relationship and a matter. Keep it general.
- Using reviews in ads without a check. When you quote a review on your website or in ads, it becomes your advertising. Some states require disclaimers on testimonials or results. Check your state’s version of Rule 7.1 before you reuse one.
What to do this quarter
- Audit your profile: total reviews, average rating, how many in the last three months, and how many have a reply.
- Turn off any review-gating setting in your review software, and make sure every client gets the Google link.
- Write the “ask moment” into the closing checklist for each practice area.
- Give staff a short template they personalize, plus your Google review link.
- Assign one person to reply to new reviews each week, with an approved list of safe replies.
- Read your state bar’s opinions on reviews and testimonials, and note anything stricter than the rules above.
Want this built and run for you? Our reviews and reputation management service sets up the process and monitors replies. It pairs with our Google Business Profile playbook and law firm SEO.
Sources
- BrightLocal, “Local Consumer Review Survey 2026,” February 2026
- Google Business Profile Help, “Tips to improve your local ranking on Google,” accessed November 2026
- Google Maps User Contributed Content Policy, “Prohibited and restricted content,” accessed November 2026
- Google Business Profile Help, “Get reviews on your Business Profile,” accessed November 2026
- Federal Trade Commission, “Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers,” accessed November 2026
- Federal Trade Commission, “FTC’s Endorsement Guides: What People Are Asking,” accessed November 2026
- Professional Ethics Committee for the State Bar of Texas, “Opinion 685,” January 2020
- New York State Bar Association, “Ethics Opinion 1286: Requesting former clients to write Google reviews,” September 2025
- Court News Ohio, “Board of Professional Conduct Issues Three Advisory Opinions,” October 2023
- American Bar Association, “Formal Opinion 496: Responding to Online Criticism,” January 2021
Want this handled for your firm?
Darkstar runs marketing for law firms end to end: SEO, content, reviews, ads, and call tracking, with a live dashboard so you always know what is working. Book a strategy call.
Book a strategy call →