Every firm with enough clients gets a one-star review eventually. Some are fair. Some come from people who were never clients. Some are flatly untrue. The review itself rarely does lasting damage. A bad reply can: lawyers have been suspended for what they wrote in response to online reviews. This guide covers what the ethics rules allow, how to get a review removed when it breaks Google’s policy, and how to keep one bad review from defining your profile.
What do the ethics rules say about replying to a bad review?
The key rule is Model Rule 1.6. A lawyer may not reveal “information relating to the representation of a client” without consent or an exception. In Formal Opinion 496 (January 2021), the ABA ethics committee applied that rule to online reviews and concluded:
- A negative review, alone, does not trigger the self-defense exception in Rule 1.6(b)(5). An online review is not a proceeding.
- Even if it did, a public reply that reveals client information “would exceed any disclosure permitted under the Rule.”
- The rule covers information that is already public and information that “could reasonably lead to the discovery” of confidential information.
- As a best practice, “lawyers should consider not responding to a negative post or review, because doing so may draw more attention to it.”
State bars have reached the same place. Texas Opinion 662 allows a “proportional and restrained” reply that reveals no confidential information. North Carolina’s 2020 Formal Ethics Opinion 1 says a lawyer may post “a professional and restrained response that does not reveal any confidential information” and may say they disagree with the review. Opinion 496 lists similar opinions from New York, Pennsylvania, Missouri, New Jersey, West Virginia, Los Angeles and San Francisco. A few jurisdictions differ at the edges (D.C.’s rule is worded differently, and Colorado’s 2019 opinion allowed limited disclosure), so read your own state’s opinion.
The cases show what is at stake. Opinion 496 collects them:
- People v. Isaac (Colo. 2016): six-month suspension for replies to former clients’ reviews that revealed criminal charges and other details about them.
- People v. Underhill (Colo. 2015): eighteen-month suspension for posting confidential and sensitive information in response to several clients’ criticism.
- In re Tsamis (Ill. 2014): public reprimand for an Avvo reply that described the client’s conduct.
- In re Skinner (Ga. 2013): the Georgia Supreme Court rejected a proposed reprimand as too lenient for disclosing client information in reply to reviews.

Should you reply at all?
There is a real tension here. The ABA suggests considering no reply. Consumers expect one: in BrightLocal’s Local Consumer Review Survey 2026, 89% of consumers said they expect owners to respond to reviews, and 42% said they are unlikely to use a business that never replies.
The way through is a short, calm reply that says nothing about the matter. Prospects reading your profile see that you are paying attention. The reviewer gets an offer to talk. No one learns anything about the client. For many firms that is the right default. Silence is a reasonable choice for a review that is obviously off-topic or that you are reporting to Google.
Who wrote it? Your reply depends on the answer
| Who posted it | What you may say | What you may not say |
|---|---|---|
| Current or former client | An invitation to talk privately; that professional obligations prevent a detailed reply | Anything about the matter, the outcome, fees, the client’s conduct, or even that they were a client |
| Someone who was never a client and not connected to any matter | That you have no record of representing them (ABA 496; NC 2020 FEO 1) | Speculation about who they are |
| Opposing party, opposing counsel, or a client’s relative | A general, restrained reply | Even “that is not what happened” can confirm you were involved in a client’s matter (ABA 496) |
| Prospective client you declined | That the firm cannot take every case, and the general reasons firms decline cases (NC 2020 FEO 1) | Information they shared in the consultation, which Rule 1.18 protects |
Replies you can adapt
Keep it to two or three sentences. Write each one fresh; BrightLocal found half of consumers are put off by generic replies. These are starting points, based on the language in the opinions above:
- Former client: “We are sorry to hear you are unhappy. Our professional obligations do not allow us to discuss any client matter here. Please call [name] at our office so we can talk about your concerns.”
- Short version, from ABA 496: “Professional obligations do not allow me to respond as I would wish.”
- Never a client: “We have no record of working with you. If we have missed something, please call our office so we can look into it.”
Then stop. If the reviewer replies again, do not reply a second time in public. If they call, listen. Opinion 496 notes that a lawyer whose former client accepts the offer to talk may offer to reduce or refund fees, but North Carolina’s opinion makes clear you may not make that offer conditional on removing the review.

When can you get a review removed?
Google does not remove reviews because they are negative or because you dispute the facts. Its help page on reporting reviews says: “Do not report a review just because you disagree with it or dislike it.” It removes reviews that break its content policy. The categories that come up most for law firms:
- Conflict of interest. Reviews from competitors, former employees, or people with another affiliation that creates a conflict.
- Fake engagement. Content “not based on a real experience,” such as a review from someone who never contacted the firm.
- Off-topic. Rants about a court, a judge, or the legal system in general rather than an experience with your firm.
- Harassment, hate speech, profanity.
- Personal information. Reviews that post a person’s private details, such as medical or financial information.
To report one, select the review in your Business Profile and choose Report, or use Google’s Reviews Management Tool. Google says evaluation “typically takes several days,” you can track the status in the tool, and if the review stays up you get one appeal. When you report, the ABA says you may state that the post is inaccurate or that the person was never a client, but you still may not disclose client information to the platform.
Should you sue or threaten to sue?
Usually not. Three things to know first:
- The FTC rule. The Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule (16 CFR Part 465, effective October 2024) bars businesses from using “unfounded or groundless legal threats,” intimidation or false accusations to get a review removed. A real claim with a legitimate legal basis is still allowed.
- Your engagement letter. The Consumer Review Fairness Act voids form-contract terms that restrict reviews or penalize people for posting them. Do not put a non-disparagement clause in a standard retainer. North Carolina has also said a lawyer cannot use a fee agreement to get advance consent to disclose confidential information in reply to reviews.
- Confidentiality still applies. North Carolina’s opinion allows a lawyer to reveal information reasonably necessary to establish a defamation claim against a former client. That is a narrow exception for an actual lawsuit, not a license to argue the facts online.
A defamation suit also tends to draw far more attention to a review than it would ever get on its own. ABA 496 cites the Streisand effect for exactly this reason. Get independent advice before you file anything.
How do you keep one bad review from defining your profile?
Do the math. A firm with four five-star reviews and one one-star review averages 4.2. A firm with 100 five-star reviews and one one-star review averages 4.96. Volume is the only lasting protection, and the way to get it is a steady, rule-compliant review process:
- Ask every client at the end of the matter, not only the ones you think are happy. Google bans businesses from selectively soliciting positive reviews, and the FTC says that kind of selective asking can mislead.
- Offer nothing in return. Google prohibits incentives for reviews.
- Never post or arrange reviews from staff, friends or family. Google treats those as conflicts of interest.
Our guide to getting more Google reviews lays out the full process, and the Google Business Profile playbook covers the rest of the profile.
Treat the pattern as data

One angry review is noise. The same complaint three times is a signal. Look for themes such as communication (“nobody called me back”), fees that surprised the client, or intake (“they never returned my call”). Each has an operational fix:
- Set a callback standard and track it.
- Send case status updates on a schedule, not only when something happens.
- Explain fees and costs in writing at the start, and again before settlement.
- Answer every intake call, or call back within minutes. Our guide to speed to lead for law firm intake covers how.
Review your reviews once a quarter with the people who run intake and case management. Fixing the cause is the only thing that reduces the next batch.
A short checklist for the next bad review
- Do not reply the same day.
- Check your records: client, former client, declined prospect, opposing party, or stranger?
- If it breaks Google’s policy, report it through the profile or the Reviews Management Tool.
- If you reply, use two or three sentences, no matter details, and an invitation to talk offline.
- Do not reply twice in public.
- If the client calls, try to fix the problem. Never make anything conditional on removing the review.
- Log the complaint theme and look for patterns each quarter.
Our reputation management service monitors reviews, drafts compliant replies for your approval, and handles policy reports.
Sources
- American Bar Association, “Formal Opinion 496: Responding to Online Criticism,” January 2021
- Professional Ethics Committee for the State Bar of Texas, “Opinion 662,” 2016
- North Carolina State Bar, “2020 Formal Ethics Opinion 1: Responding to Negative Online Reviews,” July 2021
- BrightLocal, “Local Consumer Review Survey 2026,” February 2026
- Google Business Profile Help, “Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile,” accessed November 2026
- Google Maps User Contributed Content Policy, “Prohibited and restricted content,” accessed November 2026
- Federal Trade Commission, “Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers,” accessed November 2026
- Federal Trade Commission, “Consumer Review Fairness Act: What Businesses Need to Know,” accessed November 2026
Want this handled for your firm?
Darkstar runs marketing for law firms end to end: SEO, content, reviews, ads, and call tracking, with a live dashboard so you always know what is working. Book a strategy call.
Book a strategy call →